Wind on the Withered Heath

withered heath (map)

Whence come the dragons …

Within Tolkien’s works there are only two instances in which the Withered Heath is mentioned, and both come from The Hobbit.

The first (and only) time we get to know about this place is from a comment made by Thorin during the ‘Unexpected Party’.

“And I know where Mirkwood is, and the Withered Heath where the great dragons bred.”

The Hobbit, ‘An Unexpected Party’

Whilst my curious reader-appetite has been satisfied, I’ve always wanted to know more about this particular location in Middle-earth.

The next reference in The Hobbit, comes from a poem that is sung by the Dwarves during their stay at Beorn’s house.

The first two verses are as follows:

“The wind was on the withered heath,
but in the forest stirred no leaf:”

The Hobbit, ‘Queer Lodgings’

Contrary to what I had taken for granted for years, this poem is not actually about the Withered Heath, but rather the wind itself (both as a physical element and a metaphorical meaning at the approach of dragons).

Erebor Map (Worm)

In the meantime, we have no documented reference to the Withered Heath in The Lord of the Rings. It still appears in the maps at the end of the book, but remains an unmentioned location and is not part of any of the adventures involving the Fellowship.

So what characteristics can we glean from the scarce evidence provided?

Well, at least we know it’s a windy place, thanks to the poem.

The name itself suggest that it was once a heathland, characterised by an area of shrubs, sandy ground and other flora that thrive on warm and dry conditions. At least it was once. The appearance of the dragons undoubtedly rendered the landscape virtually uninhabitable for any sort of vegetation (hence the “Withered”).

But even the geographical location can give some clues. Being a valley that ran between the two eastern arms of the Grey Mountains, and being far to the North, it might probably have been characterised by a cold and snowy climate.

How the dragons came to breed there is another mystery. If we extract some clues from The Silmarillion, we learn that Morgoth created dragons during the First Age – which would mean that at that time, the Withered Heath was an uninhabited area (as far as dragons are concerned) – and that after the end of the First Age, those of his servants that were left, fled to the East and might have sought refuge in the Grey Mountains until they settled in the valley.

“and Men dwelt in darkness and were troubled by many evil things that Morgoth had devised in the days of his dominion: demons, and dragons, and misshapen beasts, and the unclean Orcs.”

The Silmarillion, ‘Akallabêth’

Then again, Thorin’s remark that his family “was driven out of the far North, and came back with all their wealth and their tools to this Mountain [The Lonely Mountain]”, indicates that the Dwarves (specifically the Longbeards) had a colony in the Grey Mountains (such as at Mount Gundabad), until they were forced to flee by the dragons and the infestation of orcs.

withered heath illustration

We also must not forget that Smaug refers to himself as “young and tender” when he first came down from the North and sacked the Lonely Mountain. This further reinforces the concept of dragons living, breeding and thriving in the Withered Heath.

And that’s that. If you think you can help out in adding further details and information, which I’m sure to have missed, then please join in the discussion and have your say in the comments section below!

In the meantime, I’m going back to re-read The Hobbit. Maybe some sentence or piece of map will shed more light on this most intriguing of Middle-earth locations …

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Wind on the Withered Heath

  1. You say that “withered heath” only comes up twice in Tolkien’s works, and both are in “The Hobbit”. Have you discounted posthumous works. There is a reference, but it may be totally unconnected with the one in which you are concerned, but you may find it interesting all the same.

    This weekend the phrase “withered heath” came up in a tour of Tolkien’s Staffordshire relating to usage in BOLT. They believed it was inspired by his time in a camp on Cannock Case. I’ve checked BOLT2, and found this:

    “A great battle between Men at the Battle of the Sky-Roof (later called the Withered Heath), about a league from Tavrobel.”

    • Hi Michael, I actually only just found out about the BOLT2 reference. I wonder what Tolkien’s plans were once he used the location for Middle-earth …

  2. I can only add some speculation. Tolkien’s working-map of the north-west of Middle-earth shows the wide curve of the northern coast, but otherwise the vast northern region is wholly without feature, not even hinting at any remnant of the Ered Engrin. Despite the enduring cold of Morgoth, however, and the destruction wrought by the siege of Utumno and (presumably) the later Changing of the World, one might still suppose that the region was not reduced to a completely empty and uninhabitable waste, to allow for the survival of the dragons there. Species of megafauna might have wandered the tundra, great beasts like mammoth that the dragons could have hunted, while for the purposes of breeding they might naturally have been drawn to the more secluded terrain of the Withered Heath, sheltered by mountains to the north, south, and west.

  3. Well-written posts, including Michael’s and Graham’s pursuit of reasons why Tolkien included this detail. Thanks to all for sharing your insights!

  4. Simple: it’s gotta be Skyrim!

    All kidding aside, it would be interesting to write about what Tolkien would like today. I honestly believe he would love the Elder Scrolls video games. Or, at the least the detail and effort that goes into them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s